ARMENIAN ISSUE IN SOVIET-TURKISH RELATIONS IN 1921

The article studies Soviet and Turkish approaches to Armenia and its territorial problems after Sovietization of the republic. Traditionally Russia and Turkey were adversaries and the Caucasus was the main area of their active rivalry. The research shows that Moscow Treaty on Friendship and Brotherhood signed in 1921 was as not the final point of geopolitical contest. It proceeded after the treaty but was not as apparent as in the past. The unsolved Armenian issue became one of the obstacles to the full inclusion of the Transcaucasia into the Bolsheviks sphere of power. The Kemal and Bolshevik governments weren’t able to begin state building without getting over conflicts in the national peripheries. In the Armenian question, Soviet Russia turned out to be more compliant than in other Caucasian contradictions. It was important to maintain influence in Soviet Azerbaijan, to gain a foothold in Georgia and not to cede Batum to Turkey. On the other hand, Turkey refused to implement the Treaty of Alexandropol, as it needed Russian assistance in the struggle for independence.
The novelty of the research lies in the study of Armenian issue as a part of Soviet and Turkey within international and regional framework of both governments policy. The author introduced into scientific use the archival documents of the Foreign Policy Archive of the Russian Federation and the Russian Archive of Social and Political History. The unpublished material shows the diplomatic backstage that accompanied the seemingly peaceful interaction between Turkey and Soviet Russia. First, the order of events in 1921 was studied consistently, which became a turning point in the solution of the Armenian question. Armenia, having found itself an object of rivalry between two quite young states with an unstable position, lost a number of territories and the chances for restoration within the boundaries defined by the Treaty of Sevres. The denouement was also possible in connection with the position of the leading world powers, which actually left the Caucasus as a sphere of influence and were keen on resolving other problems of the post-war world

1. Archive of Foreign Policy of Russian Federation (AVP RF). F.04. Inv. 51. Papka 321. D.54859. (In Russian).

2. AVP RF. F. Referentura po Turtsii. Inv.4. Papka 5. D.10. (In Russian).

3. AVP RF. F.04. Inv.51. Papka 321 a. D.54877. (In Russian).

4. AVP RF. F.04. Inv.51. Papka 322. D.54908. (In Russian).

5. Aralov S.I. Vospominaniya sovetskogo diplomata. 1922-1923 (Memoirs of a Soviet diplomat. 1922-1923). Moscow: IMO

6. publ., 1960. 222 p. (In Russian).

7. G.V. Chicherin – I.V. Stalinu. 10 marta 1921 g. (G.V. Chicherin - I.V. Stalin. March 10, 1921) // Bol’shevistskoe rukovodstvo.

8. Perepiska. 1912 – 1927 / A.V. Kvashonkin, O.V. Khlevnyuk, L.P. Kosheleva, L.A. Rogovaya. Moscow: ROSSPEN publ.,

9. P.190 – 192. (In Russian).

10. Gusterin P.V. Zaklyuchenie Sovetsko-turetskogo dogovora 1921 goda (Conclusion of the Soviet-Turkish Treaty of 1921)

11. URL: https://proza.ru/2017/04/26/630 (Accessed: 21.08.2021). (In Russian).

12. Esayan N.K. Brestskiy mir (1918) i ego posledstviya dlya armyanskogo naroda v bor’be za natsional’noe edinstvo (The

13. Brest treaty (1918) and its consequences for the Armenian people in the struggle for national unity): thesis. St. Petersburg,

14. 172 p. (In Russian).

15. Zayavlenie Narodnogo Komissara po Delam Natsional’nostey o pobede Sovetskoy vlasti v Armenii (People’s Commissar

16. for Nationalities Affairs declaration on the victory of Soviet power in Armenia) // Dokumenty vneshney politiki SSSR. Vol.4.

17. Moscow: Gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo politicheskoy literatury publ., 1958. P.366 – 367. (In Russian).

18. Iz godovogo otcheta Narodnogo Komissariata Inostrannykh Del RSFSR k IX S»ezdu Sovetov (dekabr’ 1920 – dekabr’

19. gg.) (From the annual report of the People’s Commissariat of Foreign Affairs of the RSFSR to the IX Congress of

20. Soviets (December 1920 - December 1921) // Dokumenty vneshney politiki SSSR. Vol.4. Moscow: Gosudarstvennoe

21. izdatel’stvo politicheskoy literatury, 1958. P.727 – 767. (In Russian).

22. Kemal’ M. Put’ novoy Turtsii: [V chetyrekh tomakh]. Vol.IV. Pobeda novoy Turtsii. 1921 – 1927 (The Way of the New

23. Turkey: [In four volumes]. T.IV. The victory of the new Turkey. 1921 - 1927). Moscow: Gosudarstvennoe sotsial’noekonomicheskoe izdatel’stvo, 1934. 571 p. (In Russian).

24. Nagornyy Karabakh v 1918–1923 gg.: Sbornik dokumentov i materialov (Nagorno-Karabakh in 1918 – 1923: Collection of

25. documents and materials) / ed by. V.A. Mikaelyan. Erevan: Armenian SA publ., 1992. 756 p. (In Russian).

26. Nota Narodnogo Komissara Inostrannykh Del RSFSR Poslu Turtsii v RSFSR Ali Fuadu. 8 aprelya 1921 g. (People’s

27. Commissar for Foreign Affairs of the RSFSR note to the Ambassador of Turkey in RSFSR Ali Fuad. April 8, 1921) //

28. Dokumenty vneshney politiki SSSR. Vol. 4. Moscow: Gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo politicheskoy literatury, 1958. P.52 –

29. (In Russian).

30. Obrashchenie V. I. Lenina k kommunistam Azerbaydzhana, Gruzii, Armenii, Dagestana, Gorskoy Respubliki. 14 aprelya

31. g. (Lenin’s appeal to the communists of Azerbaijan, Georgia, Armenia, Dagestan, the Mountain Republic. April 14,

32. // Dokumenty vneshney politiki SSSR. Vol. 4. Moscow: Gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo politicheskoy literatury, 1958.

33. P.64 – 66. (In Russian).

34. Oztyurk M. Vzaimnye somneniya i nedoverie mezhdu bol’shevikami i kemalistami v period stanovleniya sovetskoturetskikh otnosheniy v 1920 – 1922 gg. (Mutual doubts and mistrust between the Bolsheviks and the Kemalists during

35. the formation of Soviet-Turkish relations in 1920 – 1922) // Izvestiya Ural’skogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriya 1:

36. Problemy obrazovaniya, nauki i kul’tury. 2010. No.5 (84). P.181 – 190. (In Russian).

37. Pravda. 1920. November 30. (In Russian).

38. Russian State Archive of Social and Political History (RGASPI). F.64. Inv.1. D.17. (In Russian).

39. RGASPI. F.85. Inv.S - Turtsiya. D. 40. (In Russian).

40. RGASPI. F.85. Inv. S/Turtsiya. D.79. (In Russian).

41. RGASPI. F.85. F.85. Inv. S/Turtsiya. D.3. (In Russian).

42. Kheyfets A.N. Sovetskaya diplomatiya i narody Vostoka. 1921 – 1927 (Soviet diplomacy and the peoples of the East.

43. – 1927). Moscow: Nauka, 1968. 326 p. (In Russian).

44. Shutova N.E. Armyanskiy vopros v rossiysko-turetskikh otnosheniyakh: 1911 – 1921 gg. (The Armenian Question in

45. Russian-Turkish Relations: 1911 - 1921): thesis. Vladimir, 2006. 197 p. (In Russian).