“CIVILIZATION STATE” OR “NATION STATE”: A PERSPECTIVE ON IRAN’S FOREIGN POLICY
https://doi.org/10.37493/2409-1030.2021.4.18
Abstract
The authors of the present paper argue that Iran’s foreign policy behavior has to be analyzed, not through the prism of “nation state” but “civilization state” if one is seeking to get it right.
Under the idea of “nation state”, the structure of the international system determines the behavior of a state. Since the nature of the international system is defined by anarchy, the neorealism mindset prescribes power accumulation to ensure survival. And offensive neorealism defines “maximization of power” and “hegemony” as the end goal of states.
But the purpose of Iran’s foreign policy is not to seek hegemony. Iran has an ancient history, a rich culture and a distinct civilization. It behaves within the framework of a “civilization state”, not a “nation state”. Iran’s influence goes beyond the border of a “nation state” because of its civilizational reach, its cultural heritage, and its historical links with modern nations in Western Asia, caucasia and central Asia. contrary to the pattern of hegemony pursued by a “nation state”, a “civilization state” focuses on cultural and human factors first. It is the flow of ‘soft power’. That’s a true way to understand Iran’s foreign policy practices.
About the Authors
S. R. Mousavinia
Allameh Tabataba’i University
Islamic Republic of Iran
Islamic Republic of Iran
PhD in international relations, Assistant Professor, Faculty of Law and Political Sciences
Tehran
A. A. Dareini
Center for Strategic Studies
Islamic Republic of Iran
Islamic Republic of Iran
Researcher and writer at the journal
Tehran
References
1. Adebahr c. Tehran calling: Understanding a New Iranian Leadership URL: https://carnegieendowment.org/files/tehran_calling.pdf (Accessed: 21.09.2021).
2. Ansari A. Politics of Modern Iran. IV, Rutledge, London & New York, 2011.
3. Antunes S., camisao I. Introducing Realism in International Relations Theory // E-International Relations. 2018. 27 February. URL: https://www.e-ir.info/2018/02/27/introducing-realism-in-international-relations-theory/
4. Barry T., Booker S, carlsen L., M. Dennis, Gershman J. A Global Good Neighbor Ethic for International Relations // Foreign Policy in Focus. Special Report, May 2005.
5. chung c.P. china’s Multilateral cooperation in Asia and the Pacific: Institutionalizing Beijing’s Good Neighbor Policy. Hong Kong: Lingnan University, Routledge, 2011.
6. Dalton L. Good Neighbor or Bad Neighbor? Explaining Powers’ Neighborhood Policies // Prepared for the 16th Annual North America Taiwan Studies conference. 2010.
7. Ehteshami A. Iran and the International community. London & NewYork: Rutledge, 1991.
8. Fidler D. competition Law and International Relations // 41 International and comparative Law Quarterly 563, Indiana University, Maurer School of Law. 1992.
9. Griffiths M. Encyclopedia of International Relations and World Politics / translated by Ali Reza Tayeb. Tehran: Ney Publication, 2009.
10. Hall J., Ikenberry J. The State. University of Minnesota Press, 1989.
11. Jackson S. china’s Good Neighbor Policy: Relations with Vietnam and Indonesia in comparative context // China An International Journal. 2009. March. P.107 – 123
12. Kazemi A. The Dilemma of Nation-Building and State Formation in the Post-Saddam Iraq // Journal of Law and Politics. 2005. 17 November.
13. Khomeini, Imam. Sahifah Noor. Volume 13. 31 June 1980. P. 90. (In Farsi).
14. Little R. A Theoretical Reassessment of the Balance of Power URL: www.allecademic.com. Edited 2007.23.05. (Accessed: 21.09.2021).
15. Mousavinia S.R. Iranian Realism. Tehran: Mokhatab Publication, 1994. (In Farsi)
16. Norkus Z. Max Weber on Nations and Nationalism: Political Economy before Political Sociology // canadian Journal of Sociology. Summer 2004. Vol. 29. No. 3.
17. Salimi H. Various Theories on Globalization. Tehran: SAMT Publications, 2005. P.142-145. (In Farsi).
18. Savory R. Iran Under the Safavids / translation by Kambiz Azizi. Tehran: Nashr Publication, 1993. (In Farsi)
19. Shabani R. A Brief History of Iran in the Afshariyeh and Zandieh Periods. Tehran: Sokhan Publication, 2008. P.523. (In Farsi)
20. Wohlforth W. The Stability of a Unipolar World // International Security. Quarterly Journal. Summer 1999. Vol. 24. No.1.
Review
For citations:
Mousavinia S.R., Dareini A.A. “CIVILIZATION STATE” OR “NATION STATE”: A PERSPECTIVE ON IRAN’S FOREIGN POLICY. Humanities and law research. 2021;(4):145-153. https://doi.org/10.37493/2409-1030.2021.4.18
Views:
200
Email this article 