The era of Catherine the Great in folk historical representations of Russians and Belarusians: the general and the special
https://doi.org/10.37493/2409-1030.2022.3.6
Abstract
The author considers the attitude of Belarusian and Russian peoples to the era of Catherine the Great as expressed through collective traditional historical knowledge. The period of its reign is evaluated as a transition from mythological time to historical. In folk texts, Catherine II often acts as the destroyer of the old and creator of the new world. The foreign policy of Catherine II has found numerous responses in Russian historical songs and traditions. The Belarusians presented the struggle of the empress with the Commonwealth, the sections of the Polish-Lithuanian state and the entry of Belarusian lands into Russia in the form of toponymic traditions and a fabulous form. Belarusian tales reflected the cooperation of the Russian government with Magnat Karol Radziwill (Pan Kakhanka) and King Stanislav Ponyatovsky. The personal life of Catherine the Great attracted the attention of all Russian people, was surrounded by many rumors, who often reflected in folk art. Communication of the empress with immigrants from a common people often occurs in narratives due to equalizing their estate status: the queen and folk heroes enter into dialogue not according to the social vertical, but on equal terms. The domestic policy of Catherine II is ambiguously evaluated in folk historical ideas. Russian texts condemn the planting of serfdom, personify anti-consonant ideas in the form of a legend about Peter III- Deliverer, and at the same time keep the memory of the liberation of the monastery peasants, weakening the duties of the Ural Cossacks, soldier-wings about the death of the empress. The existence of legends among the Old Believers about the Empress’s desire to «correct» faith indicates that the relationship of the Old Believers with the authorities did not come down to protest and social struggle. The condemnation of serfdom is more associated with specific landowners than with the empress herself. The author considers it pointless to perceive recruitment songs as a condemnation of the Russian state, since here we are not dealing with a mechanical display of the situation, but with the result of understanding socio-historical realities that fit into a wider symbolic aspect. The positive consequences of the spread of recruitment to the Belarusian lands were also noted. In the Commonwealth, Belarusian peasants never had the status of defenders of the Fatherland, since the protection of the Motherland was the privilege of the gentry. Belarusian peasants who served in the imperial army returned to themselves in the village and, telling about the service, contributed to the formation of confidence in young people in the fact that fellow villagers are involved in the defense of the Fatherland, which in this case began to be noted as a local district, and great and «their own» state. The presence of a considerable body of toponymic legends, in which Catherine the Great plays the role of a «cultural hero», is evidenced. Parallels such as texts are found in Russian legends about the «traveling» of the Empress. Usually in these texts explains the origin of the name of a particular settlement, where Catherine was driving. Locking trees along the curb by order of the empress is considered by Russian and Belarusian peasants as involvement in an important state case. The author revealed some common patterns in the development of the people’s historical ideas of Russian and Belarusians, showed how the image of the empress served as the embodiment of those hopes, illusions and stereotypes that were characteristic of the traditional political culture of the Eastern Slavs.
Keywords
About the Author
O. V. MatveyevRussian Federation
Oleg V. Matveyev, Doctor of Historical Sciences, Professor
Chair of Russian History
Krasnodar
References
1. Belaruski epas (Belarusian Epos) / ed. P. F. Glebki, I. V. Gutarau. Minsk: Orthodox Academi Navuk BSSR, 1959. 318 p. (In Belorussian).
2. Belova O. V., Petrukhin V. Ya. Folklor i knignost: mif i istoricheskiye relii (Folklore and books: myth and historical realities) / ed. S. M. Tolstaya. Moscow: Science, 2008. 263 p. (In Russian).
3. Belarus v epohu feodalizma. Sbornik dokumentov i materialov (Belarus in the era of feudalism. Collection of documents and materials) / comp. V. V. Chepko, V. V. Shatelllo. Tom Third. The reunification of Belarus with Russia and its economic development at the end of the 18th – first half of the XIX century (1772–1860). Minsk: from the Academy of Sciences of the BSSR, 1961. 624 p. (In Russian).
4. Bigday A. D. Pesni kubanskih kazakov (Songs of the Kuban Cossacks) / comp., predight., comment and note. V. G. Zakharchenko: For singing (solo, ensemble, choir) without accompanying. And with the accompany. F.-P. / In the ed. V. G. Zakharchenko. Krasnodar: Prince. Publishing House, 1992. T. I. Songs of the Black Sea Cossacks. 445 p. (In Russian).
5. Buganov A. V. Lichnosti I sobitiya v massovom soznanii russkih krestyan XIX – nachala XX vv.: istoriko-etnograficheskoe issledovanie (The individuals and events of history in the mass consciousness of the Russian peasants of the XIX th – early XX centuries: historical and ethnographic research). Moscow: Principle, 2013. 296 p. (In Russian).
6. Vereshackaya I. A. Obraz Ekaterini II v gorodskom folklore XVIII – pervoy polovini XIX veka (na primere istoricheskih anekdotov i sluhov) (The image of Catherine II in urban folklore of the XVIII – the first half of the XIX century (for example, historical jokes and rumors) // Europe in the Middle Ages and New Time: Society. Power. Culture: Materials of the VI All-Russian with the international participation of a scientific conference of young scientists. Izhevsk, December 4–5, 2018. Izhevsk: Inst. Compiled. Issl-J, 2019. P. 215–220. (In Russian).
7. Vinogradov V. V., Gromov D. V. Legendi o putesestvuyushey imperatrice (Legends about the traveling empress) // Living old. 2007. No. 3. P. 4–7. (In Russian).
8. Gigin V. Suvorov vs Kostyushko. Zabitiye fakti iz istorii vosstaniya 1794 goda v Belarusi (Suvorov vs Kostyushko. Forgotten facts from the history of the uprising of 1794 in Belarus) // Belarusian Dumka. 2009. No. 10. P. 86–95. (In Russian).
9. Gronsky A. D. A. V. Suvorov I formirovanie obraza vraga v sovremennoy Belarusi (Suvorov and the formation of the image of the enemy in modern Belarus) // Voennaja istorija Rossii XIX–XX vekov. Materialy IX Mezhdunarodnoj voenno-istoricheskoj konferencii / Ed. D. Yu. Alekseeva, A. V. Aranovich. St. Petersburg, November 25–26, 2016. St. Petersburg: SPb. GUPTD, 2016. P. 13–27. (In Russian).
10. Gronsky A. D. Konstruirovanie obraza belorusskogo nacionalnogo geroya iz uchastnika polskogo vosstaniya 1863–1864 gg. Vikentiya Konstantina Kalinovskogo (The design of the image of the Belarusian national hero from a participant in the Polish uprising of 1863–1864 Vikenty Konstantin Kalinovsky) // Russkij Sbornik: issledovanija po istorii Rossii / ed. O. R. Ayrapetov, M. Yovanovich, M. A. Kolrov, B. Menning, P. Chesti. Vol. XV. Moscow, 2013. P. 189–208. (In Russian).
11. Dnevnaya zapiska puteshestviya imperatrici Ekaterini II v Mogilev i obratno cherez Smolensk i Novgorod (A daily note of the journey of Empress Catherine II to Mogilev and back through Smolensk and Novgorod) // Sbornik Russkogo istoricheskogo obshhestva. Vol. I. St. Petersburg: Print. A. Tanschelya, 1867. P. 384–420. (In Russian).
12. Duchyts L. U., Klimkovich I. Ya. Sakralnaya geografiya Belarusi (Sacred geographer Belarus). Minsk: Literature i mastactvo, 2011. 384 p. (In Belorussian).
13. Ignatenko A. P. Borba belarusskogo naroda za vossoedinenie s Rossiey (vtoraya polovina XVII – XVIII v.) (The struggle of the Belarusian people for reunification with Russia (second half of the XVII – XVIII century). Minsk: Publishing House of BSU named after V. I. Lenin, 1974. 192 p. (In Russian).
14. Istoricheskiye pesni XVIII veka (Historical songs of the XVIII century) / ed. sub. about O. B. Alekseyeva, L. I. Emelyanov. L.: Nauka, 1971. 356 p. (In Russian).
15. Kazachestvo: obrazi kulturnoy identicnosti: sbornik folklorno-etnograficheskih materialov (Cossacks: images of cultural identity: a collection of folklore-ethnographic materials) / comp. I. A. Filippova, T. I. Rozhkova, S. A. Moiseeva. Magnitogorsk: Magnet Publishing House. State University, 2010. 202 p. (In Russian).
16. Karnovich E. P. Ocherki i rasskazi iz starinnogo bita Polshi (Essays and stories from the old life of Poland). St. Petersburg: Tipogr. F. S. Sushchinsky, 1873. 352 p. (In Russian).
17. Kozlov S. A. Ekaterina II i kazachestvo (Catherine II and Cossacks) // Reflections on Russia in the Eightenth Cttury. Köln, 2001. P. 67–72. (In Russian).
18. Cormina Z. V. Provodi v armiyu v poreformennoy Rossii. Opit etnograficheskogo analiza (Seeing off in the army in the current Russia. Experience of ethnographic analysis). Moscow: New Literary Review, 2005. 376 p. (In Russian).
19. Kostomarov N. I. Poslednie godi Rechi Pospolitoy. Istoricheskaya monografiya (Recent years of Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth). Historical monograph. Ed, 2nd. St. Petersburg, 1870. 870, IV p. (In Russian).
20. Kostomarov N. I. Istoriya kazachestva v pamyatnikah yugnorusskogo narodnogo pesennogo tvorchestva (The history of the Cossacks in the monuments of South Russian People’s Song Creativity) // Kostomarov N. I. Slavyanskaya mifologiya. Istoricheskie monografii i statyi. Moscow: Firm «Charlie», 1994. 683 p. (In Russian).
21. Kurukin I. V. Knyagna Tarakanova (Princess Tarakanova). Moscow: Young Guard, 2011. 262 p. (In Russian).
22. Legendi i Padanni (Legends and traditions) / [Warehouse. M. Ya. Grynblat i A. I. Gurski; red. Toma A. S. Freyonik]. Minsk: Woven I Tahnik, 1983. 544 p. (In Belorussian).
23. Maldis A. Stranniy korol Stanislav August (Strange King Stanislav August) / Maldis A. // URL: https://www.kurier.lt/strannyj-korol-stanislav-avgust/ (back date 12. 03. 2022). (In Russian).
24. Maslov A. V. Stanica Novopokrovskaya. К 170-letiyu so dnya osnovaniya stanici (Village Novopokrovskaya. To the 170th anniversary of the founding of the village). St. Novopokrovskaya, 1997. 65 p. (In Russian).
25. Matveyev O. V. Narodnaya toponimiya v organizacii prostranstva istoricheskoy pamyati kubanskih kazakov (People’s toponymy in organizing the space of the historical memory of the Kuban Cossacks) // Slavjano-adygskie kul’turnye svjazi: istorija i sovremennost’. Materialy Pjatyh nauchnyh chtenij, posvjashhennyh Dnju slavjanskoj pis’mennosti i kul’tury i Godu rossijskoj istorii (Majkop, 2012). Maykop: Publishing House Magarin O. G., 2012. P. 111–124.
26. Melnikov G. Nebesnie zastupniki. Svyatini slavyanskogo mira (Heavenly Intercessors. Shrines of the Slavic world) // Rodina. 2006. No. 4. P. 49–53. (In Russian).
27. Narodnaya proza (People’s Prose) / comp., intr. art., selection texts and comments. S. N. Azbelian. Moscow: Russian book, 1992. 608 p. (In Russian).
28. Narodnaya proza Kubani (People’s Prose of Kuban) / compilier L. B. Martynenko, I. V. Uvarova. Krasnodar: KubSU, 2003. 240 p. (In Russian).
29. Ocheli V. I. Polsky «analog» gruzinskogo srednevekovogo eposa «Eteriani» (Polish «analogue» of the Georgian medieval epic «Eteria») // Studia Polonoslavica. Moscow: Publishing House of Moscow State University, 2014. P. 196–203. (In Russian).
30. Pesni i predaniya o Razint i Pugacheve (Songs and legends about Razin and Pugachev) / ed. A. N. Lozanova. Moscow. - Leningrad: Akademia, 1935. 423 p. (In Russian).
31. Pigin A. V. Kak Ekaterina II v staruyu veru pereshla (As Catherine II converted to the old faith) // Commentarii litterarum. Ad honorem viri doctissimi Valentini Golovin / Ed. M. L. Lurie. St. Petersburg: Publishing House «Pushkin House», 2020. P. 96–103. (In Russian).
32. Popova E. V. Predaniya o puteshestvii imperatrici Ekaterini II v kontekste istoricheskoy prozi v seleniyah na Sibirskom trakte (Traditions about the journey of Empress Catherine II in the context of historical prose in villages in the Siberian tract) // Tradicionnaja kul’tura. 2013. No. 4. P. 70–77. (In Russian).
33. Prigarin A. A. «Narodnie predaniya» i «istoriografiya»: urovni istoricheskogo (so)znaniya lipovan («Folk legends» and «historiography»: levels of historical consciousness / knowledge of Lipovans) // Шаги-Steps. 2016. Vol. 2. No. 4. P. 114–149. (In Russian).
34. Proklyatie Ponyatovskogo: lubovnika Ekaterini II i poslednego korolya Polsi (Curse of Ponyatovskiy, the lover of Catherine II and the last King of Poland) // URL: https://newsroyal.ru/proklyatie-ponyatovskogo-liubovnika-ek/ (Accessed: 10. 03. 2022). (In Russian).
35. Russian State Military Historical Archive (RGVIA). F. 643. Inv. 1. D. 4. (In Russian).
36. Russkie narodnie skazki kazakov-nekrasovcev (Russian folk fairy tales of Nekrasovsky Cossacks) / comp. by F. V. Tumilevich. Rostov-on-Don: Publishing House, 1958. 269 p. (In Russian).
37. Serzhputovski A. K. Kazki i Apavjadanni Belarusau Slutskaga Paveta (Tales and traditions of the Belarusians of the Slutsk region). Minsk: Universiteckae, 2000. 270 p. (In Belorussian).
38. Skazki (Fairy tales): Book 3 / comp. by U. G. Kruglov. Moscow: Sow. Russia, 1989. 624 p. (In Russian).
39. Chernyavskaya Yu. V. Belorusi. Ot «tuteysih» k nacii (Belarusians. From the «Tirstiest» to the nation). Minsk: Fuanform, 2010. 512 p. (In Russian).
40. Chistov K. V. Russkie narodnie socialno-utopicheskie legendi XVII – XIX vv. (Russian folk social and utopian legends of the XVII – XIX centuries). Moscow: Science, 1967. 342 p. (In Russian).
Review
For citations:
Matveyev O.V. The era of Catherine the Great in folk historical representations of Russians and Belarusians: the general and the special. Humanities and law research. 2022;9(3):411-422. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.37493/2409-1030.2022.3.6